Omega-3 consumption have little positive effect on mental health

0
124

Omega-3 fats have little or no effect on anxiety and depression according to new research from the University of East Anglia.

Increased consumption of omega-3 fats is widely promoted globally because of a common belief that it will protect against, or even reverse, conditions such as anxiety and depression.

But a systematic review published today in the British Journal of Psychiatry, finds that omega-3 supplements offer no benefit.

Omega-3 is a type of fat. Small amounts are essential for good health and can be found in the food that we eat including nuts and seeds and fatty fish, such as salmon.

Omega-3 fats are also readily available as over-the-counter supplements and they are widely bought and used.

The research team looked at 31 trials of adults with and without depression or anxiety. More than 41,470 participants were randomised to consume more long-chain omega-3 fats (fish oils), or maintain their usual intake, for at least six months

They found that the supplements had little or no effect in preventing depression or anxiety symptoms.

Lead author Dr Lee Hooper, from UEA’s Norwich Medical School, said: “Our previous research has shown that long-chain omega-3 supplements, including fish oils, do not protect against conditions such as heart disease, stroke, diabetes or death.

“This large systematic review included information from many thousands of people over long periods. Despite all this information, we don’t see protective effects.”

“The most trustworthy studies consistently showed little or no effect of long-chain omega-3 fats on depression or anxiety, and they should not be encouraged as a treatment.”

Omega 3 fats are also readily available as over-the-counter supplements and they are widely bought and used.

Dr Katherine Deane, from UEA’s School of Health Sciences, said: “Oily fish can be a very nutritious food as part of a balanced diet.

“But we found that there is no demonstrable value in people taking omega-3 oil supplements for the prevention or treatment of depression and anxiety.

“Considering the environmental concerns about industrial fishing and the impact it is having on fish stocks and plastic pollution in the oceans, it seems unhelpful to continue to swallow fish oil tablets that give no benefit.”

Funding: The research was funded by the World Health Organisation.


Neurological and mental disorders continue to be on the rise. The Global Burden of Disease Report 2017 states that from 2007 to 2017, the number of neurological disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) increased by 20.5%, while mental health DALYs increased by 13.5%.1 

Countries with a high sociodemographic index (SDI) are significantly more affected than countries with a low SDI, which suggests a causal role of the Western lifestyle.1 

Diet, physical activity, and social structures are critical factors that have been linked to increases in neuropsychiatric and other disorders that are usually referred to as lifestyle diseases.

Concerning diet, high intakes of fruit, vegetables, fish, and whole grains have been recommended to reduce such risk.24 

The role of nutrition for preventing and treating neuropsychiatric disorders is increasingly being recognized, and it has recently been stated that ‘nutrition and nutraceuticals should now be considered as mainstream elements of psychiatric practice’.35

Research on omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (n-3 PUFAs) has grown exponentially since researchers from Denmark visited Greenland in 1970 to study why the cardiovascular mortality among the Inuit population was considerably lower than in the Western countries.6 

The researchers related their findings to the diet of the Inuit, which consisted mainly of fish and meat from seals, whales, sea birds, and fur-bearing animals. These foods contain large amounts of n-3 PUFAs.6

 In the following decades, the health effects of n-3 PUFAs were studied extensively, covering almost all medical conditions, including neurological and psychiatric disorders. Such studies found that more isolated arctic populations with traditional lifestyles and diets have lower rates of depression, anxiety, and suicidality than less isolated or non-arctic populations. These findings have been associated with diet-related factors, that is, n-3 PUFA intake.7

Research has shown that the significance of n-3 PUFAs for neuropsychiatric disorders is based on their crucial role in neuronal cell functioning. Lipid imbalance in intracellular biochemical processes and neuronal cell membranes may lead to changes in brain functioning that can cause or aggravate neuropsychiatric disorders.8 

The aim of this paper is to give an introduction to the clinical effects of n-3 PUFAs in various neuropsychiatric disorders and their underlying biochemical mechanisms. In addition, the reader will be enabled to identify common methodological weaknesses of clinical studies on n-3 PUFAs. For more in-depth reviews on the role of n-3 PUFAs in specific diseases, the reader is referred to the respective references.

What are n-3 PUFAs and how do they work?

Omega-3 fatty acids (FAs) are a type of PUFA. Polyunsaturated means that their carbon chain contains two or more double bonds. Omega (ω) is the last letter in the Greek alphabet, and omega-3 denotes that the first of these double bonds is located between the 3rd and the 4th carbon atom seen from the last (the omega-) atom of the carbon chain (Figure 1). Another nomenclature uses the Latin letter n instead of the Greek ω. Both nomenclatures are common.

An external file that holds a picture, illustration, etc.
Object name is 10.1177_2045125319858901-fig1.jpg
Figure 1.
The chemical structure of the two most important n-3 fatty acids, docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA).

There are over 30 different PUFAs. In addition to n-3 PUFAs, there are n-5, n-6, n-7, and n-9 PUFAs. Of these, n-3 and n-6 PUFAs play the most important biological roles, and the quantitative balance between n-3 and n-6 PUFAs is believed to be a crucial factor in many disease states (discussed in the following). Table 1 gives an overview of biologically important n-3 and n-6 PUFAs.


Table 1.

Biologically important n-3 and n-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs).

Common nameLipid name
n-3 PUFAsAlpha-linolenic acid (ALA)*18:3n3
Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA)**20:5n3
Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA)**22:6n3
n-6 PUFAsLinoleic acid (LA)*18:2n6
Gamma-linolenic acid (GLA)18:3n6
Arachidonic acid (AA)20:4n6

*Essential fatty acids.**Conditionally essential fatty acids.

There are several different n-3 PUFAs, the biologically most relevant ones being alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Humans cannot produce ALA and therefore ALA is one of two essential FAs that must be supplied by diet [the other essential FA is linoleic acid (LA), which is an n-6 PUFA]. ALA is found in seeds, nuts, and plant oils. While no major biological effects of ALA on cells or tissues have been identified so far, its biological value lies mainly in being a substrate for the synthesis of other PUFAs.9 

The human body is not able to synthesize DHA and EPA de novo, but can produce them from ALA. However, this capacity is very limited and, in addition, subject to polymorphisms of the genes coding for the involved enzymes (fatty acid desaturase and elongase).10 

Reported conversion rates of ALA to EPA are 0.2–6%, and 0.05% or less for DHA. Women seem to possess a higher conversion capacity than men.9

Since humans can convert only an insufficient proportion of ALA to EPA and DHA, the latter two are classified as conditionally essential FAs.9 

Dietary sources of EPA and DHA are fish, shellfish, and meat from marine mammals, for example, seals and whales. Like humans, these animals do not produce n-3 PUFAs themselves to a relevant degree. Instead, EPA and DHA are synthesized by marine algae, which are eaten by small fish that in turn are food for larger animals.

The phospholipids of the brain’s gray matter and the retina contain high concentrations of DHA and arachidonic acid (AA, which is an n-6 PUFA), which supports the notion that long-chain PUFAs play an essential role in the development and maintenance of proper central nervous system (CNS) function.1114 

Owing to the many double bonds, PUFAs are more bulky than saturated fatty acids (SFAs; Figure 1). When PUFAs instead of SFAs are incorporated into the phospholipid layer of the cell membrane, the physicochemical properties of the membrane become altered; it becomes less rigid and more fluid.

More specifically, phase behavior (how a membrane’s mobility changes with temperature) is shifted to the left, that is, more fluid, while elastic compressibility (relative volume change/thickness in response to stress), permeability (passive diffusion of molecules through the membrane), fusion (two membranes merge into one), flip-flop (transverse diffusion of membrane constituents, that is, from the outer layer to the inner layer or vice versa), and protein activity become increased.15 

Incorporation of n-3 PUFAs into cell membranes also leads to reorganization of lipid raft formation. Lipid rafts are membrane domains that contain clusters of receptors and proteins involved in signal transduction.

Hence, all these mechanisms affect the function of membrane proteins, such as receptors, membrane-bound enzymes, G-proteins, and ion channels, thereby modulating intracellular and intercellular signaling pathways in neurons and other cell types.16,17 

Of special interest for the etiology, prophylaxis, and treatment of neuropsychiatric disorders is the involvement of n-3 PUFAs in the fetal development and later maintenance of dopaminergic pathways in the brain.18

Another way in which n-3 PUFAs may positively affect CNS functions such as cognition and behavior is by affecting the gut’s microbiota composition, its fatty acid composition, and by reducing intestinal inflammation, which in summary affects the gut–brain axis. This has been demonstrated in both animal and human studies.1921

n-3 PUFAs are, apart from being building blocks in cell membranes, biotransformed to eicosanoids such as prostaglandins, thromboxanes, and leukotrienes, as well as endocannabinoids and other lipid-based signaling substances that are involved in many biochemical processes in the body, for example, inflammation and immune responses.

Eicosanoids derived from n-3 PUFAs, such as prostacyclin I3 and thromboxane A3, are generally considered anti- inflammatory, antithrombotic, vasodilatory, and antineoplastic. The anti-inflammatory effects of n-3 PUFAS most probably contribute to their neuroprotective effects in various neuropsychiatric conditions (see the following).

By contrast, signal substances derived from n-6 PUFAs such as AA or LA, for example, prostaglandin E2 or thromboxane A2, have mainly opposite effects.

Therefore, the balance between n-6- and n-3 PUFAs has been identified as a critical biomarker for chronic disease.22 The WHO has stated that there should be an optimal balance in the dietary intake constituted by n-6 and n-3 PUFAs.23 

However, n-6 PUFAs are found in large amounts in most plant oils, and the consumption of plant oils has exploded in the past decades while fish consumption has steadily declined.22 Consequently, the Western diet is characterized by an over-supply of n-6 PUFAs, a deficiency in n-3 PUFAs, and, thus, a striking imbalance between these two.22

All PUFAs are highly susceptible to oxidation. Accordingly, oxidative stress in the body has a large impact on lipid metabolism including PUFAs. Lipid peroxidation leads to membrane phospholipid degradation, directly affecting cell membrane function.24

 Similarly, nutritional supplements that contain PUFAs must be protected by effective antioxidants. Fish and other sources of marine n-3 PUFAs contain polyphenols and other compounds that protect n-3 PUFAs from oxidation in vivo. However, these compounds are removed during the production of commercial n-3 preparations, mainly because they also account for the typical fishy taste and odor.

Therefore, most manufacturers add vitamin E as a fat-soluble antioxidant. Despite this, studies from different countries have consistently shown that most n-3 PUFA preparations that are sold over the counter are oxidized (rancid) to varying degrees.2527 Obviously, decomposed n-3 PUFAs have lost their characteristic biological properties.

Even worse, peroxidation products of PUFAs may under certain conditions promote oxidative stress, a pro-inflammatory environment, DNA damage, and clinical deterioration.28,29 Since most interventional clinical studies use ordinary fish oil capsules, this may be a major reason why some interventional studies did not find a beneficial effect of n-3 PUFAs or even an increase in clinical symptoms.30

Many authorities and professional societies recommend certain amounts of daily intake of n-3 PUFAs, but they do not provide corresponding reference ranges for n-3 PUFA blood levels.31 Nonetheless, free serum n-3 PUFAs, erythrocyte membrane n-3 PUFAs, and whole blood phospholipid n-3 PUFAs can be measured by many laboratories and used as biomarkers to estimate the risk for disease and to monitor the efficacy of n-3 PUFA substitution with a given commercial preparation.

The two best documented biomarkers are (1) the n-3 index, which is the combined percentages of EPA plus DHA measured in erythrocyte membrane FAs, and (2) the n-6/n-3 ratio, which is the ratio of n-6 FA and n-3 FA percentages.32 

A high n-6/n-3 ratio and a low n-3 index are generally associated with poorer medical condition. In Western populations, the average n-3 index varies from 2.9% to 7.7% while a value of 8–11% is required for optimal protection against cardiovascular diseases.3336 The average n-6/n-3 ratio in Western countries is 15–21 while a value below 5 is generally recommended.28 T

he predictive value of the n-6/n-3 ratio has recently been questioned and the n-3 index has been suggested as a more robust biomarker. It should be noted, however, that the author of that paper may be biased, as he has commercial interests related to n-3 index testing.32,37

The reason why the PUFA status should be measured in red blood cells and not in plasma is that the plasma fatty acid profile may change within hours, depending on the type of food and time after intake, while red blood cells have a half-life of 120 days, which provides a much more stable measure of the PUFA content of cell membranes. Moreover, the PUFA content of red blood cell membranes is highly correlated to the PUFA content of major organs.3840

Effects of n-3 PUFAs in various neuropsychiatric disorders

The effects of n-3 PUFAs have been studied in a large variety of neurological and psychiatric disorders. In the following, a selection of them are discussed. Additional neuropsychiatric disorders that are not discussed in detail are summarized at the end of this section.

Depression

Numerous epidemiological and interventional studies have accumulated strong evidence for a connection between n-3 PUFA status and depression.41,42 Low fish consumption and a low omega-3 index are clearly correlated with a higher risk of developing a major depression.4348 Accordingly, an increase in the omega-3 index reduced the risk and the severity of depressive symptoms in several clinical studies. One of them found that for each 1% increase in the n-3 index, the risk of developing depression was reduced by 28%.45,49,50 This correlates with findings from clinical studies in nonpsychiatric conditions.33 Depressed patients also exhibit higher n-6/n-3 ratios than nondepressed controls.5052

Various studies found an inverse correlation between dietary intake of n-3 PUFAs and the severity of depressive symptoms including suicidality.28,48,5258 Although some of these studies produced neutral results, several meta-analyses confirmed the antidepressant effects of dietary EPA and DHA.5963 Daily doses between 1 and 3.5 g have produced therapeutic effects.42 It is unclear whether EPA and DHA differ in their antidepressant efficacy, as each of them independently has been proposed as the strongest mediator of the beneficial effects of n-3 PUFAs in depression.29,46,60,64,65 Interestingly, the DHA amount in blood phospholipids, but not the EPA amount, distinguished responders from nonresponders in a recent interventional study.66

The efficacy of n-3 PUFAs in special subpopulations such as children, adolescents, elderly patients with underlying comorbidities, or in related conditions such as bipolar disorder, is only incompletely studied. Most data available so far suggest beneficial effects of supplementation with n-3 PUFAs in these patient groups.29,6772

How n-3 PUFAs exert their antidepressant action is not fully understood. At present, it appears that multiple unspecific mechanisms of action are responsible. Modulation of G-protein signaling via G-protein coupled receptors and effects on lipid raft formation has been suggested as one possible mechanism.73 Other mechanisms such as modulation of pro-inflammatory mediators, and changes in telomerase levels may also play a role.48,57,65,74

Schizophrenia

Schizophrenic patients show a marked depletion of essential FAs, particularly AA and DHA, in red blood cell membranes. These two FAs are the most abundant FAs in the human brain, which suggests that they play a crucial role in the function of the CNS.1113 Accumulating evidence from experimental and clinical studies has led to the ‘membrane hypothesis’, which postulates dietary-related changes in PUFA-dependent membrane function as a major pathophysiologic mechanism in schizophrenia.75,76 Accordingly, diet changes that lead to increased membrane levels of n3-PUFAs can have significant effects on schizophrenic symptoms.77

Several randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trials have studied the efficacy of n-3 PUFA supplementation in schizophrenia. While some yielded positive results,7880 others found partial efficacy such as reduced need for antipsychotic medication,81,82 or no beneficial effects at all.30,83 However, the observation time in most studies was only 8–12 weeks and as mentioned earlier in this article, sustained changes in membrane function may take longer time to develop. The only long-term study so far, a 6-month, randomized, placebo-controlled trial in first-episode schizophrenic patients, found a significantly greater decrease in the intensity of symptoms and an improved level of functioning in the n-3 group than in the placebo group.84

Disturbances in cortical membrane FA homeostasis have been identified as a pathological aspect of schizophrenia, which is one of several possible explanations for the efficacy of n-3 PUFAs.75,76,85 Beyond membrane-related effects on neuronal cell signaling pathways, n-3 PUFAs may act through additional mechanisms, for example, modulation of dopaminergic pathways in the mesolimbic system.18 In an in vitro model mimicking the involvement of viral infection in the development of neuropsychiatric disorders, n-3 PUFAs showed significant neuroprotective effects.86 In addition, clinical studies in schizophrenic patients found that n-3 PUFA substitution leads to an increase in telomerase levels as well as a reduction in oxidative stress.84,87,88

ADHD

It is well established that dietary depletion of n-3 PUFAs during fetal development and early childhood may have adverse effects on brain development, neurodevelopmental outcomes, and cognitive health.54,89,90 For example, low maternal intake of n-3 fatty acids during pregnancy is correlated with lower verbal intelligence, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), dyslexia, dyspraxia, autism, and impaired social behavior in the child.89,9193

Epidemiological studies found that children with ADHD have lower blood levels of n-3 PUFAs than controls.9396 Accordingly, several randomized, placebo-controlled interventional trials reported positive effects of dietary supplementation with n-3 PUFAs in ADHD.94,95,9799 However, other trials found only small or no therapeutic effects. Hence, some meta-analyses stated that there is evidence for n-3 PUFAs as a supplement to established therapies while others concluded that the currently available evidence is inconclusive.94,100107 Major reasons for these contradictory conclusions are different selection of studies, small sample sizes, variability of inclusion criteria, variability of the type and dosage of supplementation, short follow-up times, and different cognitive and behavioral outcome parameters.101,102,105 Moreover, some studies that used multiple outcome parameters observed therapeutic effects in some but not all of them.

While the pathophysiology of ADHD is not fully understood, it is generally accepted that brain dopaminergic and noradrenergic systems play a central role. This hypothesis is supported by the clinical effectiveness of medicines such as methylphenidate and amphetamine. In animal experiments, n-3 PUFA depletion induced symptoms that mimic ADHD in humans, while symptom severity was inversely correlated with dietary n-3 PUFA intake. The significance of n-3 PUFAs for the regulation of dopaminergic pathways in ADHD has recently been reviewed.18

PTSD

It has long been known that both physical and psychological stress are associated with altered blood levels of free fatty acids including long-chain PUFAs.108,109 Cross-sectional studies reported lower n-3 PUFA blood levels in patients with PTSD than in healthy controls.110,111 Similarly, longitudinal studies found an inverse relation between blood levels of n-3 PUFAs and the risk of developing PTSD after accidental injury.112,113

However, only a few clinical trials examined possible effects of supplementation with n-3 PUFAs on post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and they produced mixed results. While one study found that EPA but not DHA reduces the risk of developing PTSD in patients with accidental injury,114 another study found ameliorated psychophysiological stress responses after combined supplementation with a high dose of DHA + a low dose of EPA.115 A study in survivors of the great earthquake in Japan 2011 found an effect of 1568 mg DHA + 157 mg EPA in women, but not in men.116 Further clinical research is clearly needed.

Different mechanisms could mediate possible effects of n-3 PUFAs in PTSD and other stress-related conditions. Since PTSD is associated with increased interleukin 6, interleukin 1β, tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFα), and interferon γ levels, it has been suggested that the expression of these cytokines may be normalized by the anti-inflammatory and neuroprotective actions of n-3 PUFAs.117 This hypothesis is supported by experimental findings.118 Another, more specific mechanism may be an increase in brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) induced by n-3 PUFAs, which leads to induction of hippocampal neurogenesis by which fear-related memory might be cleared.119121 A more recent hypothesis assumes a role of the n-3 PUFA-derived endocannabinoids 2-docosahexaenoylglycerol (2-DHG) and docosahexaenoylethanolamine (DHA-EA) in reducing psychological distress.122

Dementia

The clinical efficacy of established medications for Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and other dementias is weak, and new treatment options are urgently warranted. A large body of evidence suggests a positive correlation between n-3 PUFAs and cognition, and most (but not all) interventional studies reported beneficial effects of n-3 PUFAs on cognitive outcome and quality of life in patients with AD, especially with early stage AD and mild cognitive impariment.20,123128 While some interventional studies reported neutral results, a recent meta-analysis by Zhang et al. found that n-3 PUFAs from fishery products are associated with a lower risk of cognitive decline in AD patients.129 This is supported by a study in healthy subjects where both the n-3 index and the n-6/n-3 ratio were correlated with cognitive function as well as hippocampal and total brain volume.130,131

Experimental evidence implies biological plausibility for beneficial effects of n-3 PUFAs in dementia. Antioxidant actions, enhanced brain plasticity, and other mechanisms that are more directly related to the specific pathology displayed in dementia, such as anti-inflammatory, anti- amyloid and anti-tau effects, have been demonstrated.132134 DHA may have stronger neuroprotective properties than EPA as DHA-deficiency is highly correlated with cortical and hippocampal atrophy.135,136 Experimental data also show that DHA regulates apoptotic processes and the level of Aβ-induced lipid peroxides, which has positive effects on the survival of neurons.137 In addition, DHA increases dendrite density and reduces beta amyloid and tau protein load.138141

In addition to these mechanisms, n-3 PUFAs may ameliorate cognitive dysfunction via indirect effects. Both AD and vascular dementia are associated with cardiovascular events such as microinfarctions in the brain, and it has been shown that prevention of cardiovascular morbidity with n-3 PUFAs has beneficial effects on cognitive function.142,143

Factors that might explain the mixed results of clinical studies on n-3 PUFAs in dementia are the large variations in study design (e.g. RCTs versus epidemiological studies), study populations, observation times and follow-up periods, variations in n-3 dosages, different biomarkers for fatty acid status, different cognitive outcome parameters as well as different (and partly low) sensitivity in the neuropsychological tests. Notably, it has been suggested that n-3 PUFAs may exert their most significant effects on cognition before disease onset. This is of special importance in AD which is a disease that probably starts decades before clinical symptoms become overt.131,144

Parkinson’s disease

After AD, Parkinson’s disease (PD) is the second most common neurodegenerative disorder with a prevalence of about 2% in people over 65 years.145 While the etiology of PD is still not fully understood, its pathophysiology is well studied and involves dysfunction of the mitochondria and inflammatory and oxidative stress reactions.146148 Despite this knowledge, the standard pharmacological approach to treat PD is still more or less limited to enhancing dopaminergic signaling. However, dopaminergic medications may lose effect over time and can induce serious side effects.149,150

Only few clinical studies examined n-3 PUFAs in PD. All but one reported beneficial effect. Observational studies found a correlation between higher intake of n-3 PUFAs from fish and lower prevalence of PD.151,152 In the Rotterdam Study, a prospective population-based cohort study of 5289 subjects, each SD increase of energy-adjusted intake of PUFAs reduced the risk of developing PD by 34 %.153 A randomized, double-blind placebo-controlled trial found that supplementation with n-3 PUFAs improved clinical symptomatology in PD patients, as indicated by a decrease in the average Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale score.154 A case–control study, however, found that dietary intake of n-3 PUFAs was not predictive for the risk of developing PD.155

Part of the positive effects of n-3 PUFAs on PD is probably due to their neuroprotective properties, since oxidative stress and neuroinflammation are ameliorated by n-3 PUFAs.156 Indeed, a clinical study found that supplementation with n-3 PUFAs decreased C-reactive protein and increased glutathione concentrations as well as total antioxidant capacity.154 These results are supported by experimental findings demonstrating a reduction of inducible nitric oxide synthase activity in the CNS and increased levels of BDNF after supplementation with n-3 PUFAs.120,157,158 Apart from neuroprotective effects, n-3 PUFAs may enhance dopaminergic signal transduction through different mechanisms.18


Source:
University of East Anglia
Media Contacts:
Lisa Horton – University of East Anglia
Image Source:
The image is adapted from the University of East Anglia news release.

Original Research: Open access
“Omega-3 and polyunsaturated fat for prevention of depression and anxiety symptoms: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials”. Lee Hooper et al.
British Journal of Psychiatry doi:10.1192/bjp.2019.234.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Questo sito usa Akismet per ridurre lo spam. Scopri come i tuoi dati vengono elaborati.