Owning items that promote e-cigarettes and other alternative tobacco products doubles the likelihood that a young person will try these products, a new study led by the Stanford University School of Medicine has found.
The finding illustrates the influence of such marketing on teenagers.
The study, which will be published online May 17 in JAMA Network Open, followed 757 California teens for a year.
But some participants owned marketing materials for these products, such as coupons, samples and branded hats or T-shirts.
“We wanted to see how owning promotional materials would affect young people’s use later on,” said the study’s lead author, Hoda Magid, Ph.D., a postdoctoral scholar in health research and policy.
“The increase in use of alternative tobacco products poses a threat to the decades of hard work that public health experts have done to reduce tobacco use,” Magid said.
“We need to know trajectories of use of alternative tobacco products,” said the study’s senior author, Bonnie Halpern-Felsher, Ph.D., professor of pediatrics.
Understanding when and why youth start using such products is important for stemming the tide of addiction to them, she said.
Research has shown exposure to marketing of combustible tobacco products increases the likelihood of youth initiation of use,3 and marketing of these products has long been regulated due to a history of using content appealing to youth, such as associating cigarettes with independence, adventure, and social positioning.4
Currently there are no marketing restrictions on e-cigarettes in the United States (US) beyond avoiding misleading claims.5
Previous studies have found youth exposure to e-cigarette ads is increasing,6 and these ads are using appeals to e-cigarettes’ ‘coolness’, modernity, association with social status, romance, and celebrities in marketing.2,7,8
Unsurprisingly, the rates of e-cigarette use among youth aged 10-17 are increasing,9 and exposure to e-cigarette marketing has been associated with susceptibility to use e-cigarettes among never e-cigarette users.10–13
However, there has been no systematic exploration of the appeals being utilized in e-cigarette advertisements, which has limited our ability to identify youth-focused marketing efforts in the US and to inform regulation of e-cigarette marketing.
The content appealing to youth (CAY) index is a measure of media content features found to be appealing to youth that was previously developed for use in alcohol ads.14
In a previous study, triangulated data from a content analysis of televised alcohol ads, data on youth exposure to those ads, and self-reported youth and adult alcohol consumption showed that high CAY scores were positively associated with youth, but not adult alcohol consumption by alcohol brand.14
Modifying the index to be applicable to e-cigarettes, we used this index to conduct a content analysis to explore the use of youth appealing features in e-cigarette marketing in the US.
Restrictions on conventional smokes
While marketing to minors and providing samples is illegal for all tobacco products, providing coupons and branded promotional items such as T-shirts and hats is not illegal for most alternative tobacco products, except smokeless tobacc
Enforcement of all policies is lacking, Halpern-Felsher said.
“The problem is that the FDA has been very slow to enact new or enforce existing laws and regulations for e-cigarettes,” Halpern-Felsher said.
“Right now, the FDA is not going after manufacturers who have not put in an application to market e-cigarettes.”
The Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act requires all tobacco companies to submit premarket applications to FDA and receive agency authorization before putting a product on the market, but the compliance dates have been extended to 2021 or 2022, depending on the product.
This means thousands of e-cigarettes and other alternative tobacco products are being marketed without any FDA review.
When the study began, participants were 13 to 19 years old and attended California high schools.
They completed questionnaires asking whether they had ever used traditional cigarettes or any alternative tobacco products, and whether they or their friends owned promotional items – such as coupons, free samples, T-shirts, posters and hats – for any type of nicotine product.
The researchers asked similar questions about the use of cigarettes and alternative tobacco products a year later and analyzed changes in the teens’ use of e-cigarettes and other tobacco products as a function of owning or receiving promotional materials.
Over the course of the study, 129 participants, or 17 percent, began using alternative tobacco products but not traditional cigarettes.
Twelve participants began using traditional cigarettes alone or in combination with alternative tobacco products.
Before adjusting for confounding factors, teens who owned promotional items were found to be 2.23 times as likely to try alternative tobacco products as those who did not own such items.
After adjusting for age, gender, race/ethnicity, maternal education level and baseline alcohol and cigarette use, the teens who owned promotional materials were 2.13 times as likely as their peers to begin using alternative tobacco products.
When teens who had tried both alternative tobacco products and cigarettes during the year were included in the analysis, the influence of owning promotional materials did not reach statistical significance.
The findings provide evidence that ownership of marketing materials is strongly associated with more young people using e-cigarettes and other alternative tobacco products, the researchers said.
The findings clearly show that no tobacco company, including any e-cigarette company, should be allowed to provide coupons, free samples or other marketing materials to teens, and suggest that the FDA should further restrict and enforce such marketing techniques, Halpern-Felsher said.
“Manufacturers say they’re not marketing to teens, but teens are reporting owning these promotional items, and they’re reporting use of alternative tobacco products,” Magid said.
Current restrictions and laws that make marketing cigarettes and other tobacco products to minors should be enforced for all nicotine-containing products, she added.
Journal information: JAMA Network Open
Provided by Stanford University Medical Center