Persistent cough post Omicron

0
160

A new phenomenon has been observed in recent months – persistent post covid cough.
Let us try to clarify its origins.

The COVID-19 pandemic, caused by the novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2, has had an unprecedented effect on global health since its discovery in Wuhan, China.1, 2 Even in countries where the first pandemic wave of the virus was controlled, second or third waves are happening or have been predicted to occur.

With limited availability of effective vaccines, measures to reduce disease spread—such as physical distancing, wearing masks, and avoiding crowds—remain key strategies to combat the infection. Similar to the more common but less serious infections of the common cold or flu, cough is a key symptom of COVID-19 in the acute phase of the infection, and one that persists in the post-infective phase.

Cough is not only distressing to patients, but also increases the risk of community transmission by respiratory droplets.3 

Stigmatisation of patients with cough can occur, leading to social isolation,4 particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic. Identifying ways to control COVID-19-associated cough could help to prevent community transmission and disease spread, as well as removing the stigma of this symptom.

Evidence-based treatment options for COVID-19 cough are needed because patients with cough caused by common viral infections, including cold and flu, frequently resort to over-the-counter cough medicines. Patients with chronic cough also often seek antitussive therapies, but it is unknown whether such approaches are effective in post-COVID cough patients.

We propose that it is important to consider cough as a target of intervention in the management of COVID-19 and post-COVID syndrome. However, we currently have little understanding of the mechanisms underlying COVID-19-associated cough. In this Personal

View, we review the knowledge that has accumulated on cough in COVID-19, and discuss neuroinflammatory and neuroimmune mechanisms that could potentially underlie COVID-19-associated cough based on our understanding of the pathogenesis of COVID-19 and of the cough associated with other respiratory viruses. We conclude by discussing the management of acute and chronic COVID-19 cough and future directions for research and clinical practice.

Key messages

  • •Acute COVID-19-associated cough with fever and a loss of taste and smell is common; chronic cough after SARS-CoV-2 infection occurs less frequently, but is common in the so-called post-COVID syndrome (long COVID), in which it is usually associated with other symptoms, including chronic fatigue, dyspnoea, chronic pain, and cognitive impairment (brain fog)
  • •Optimal management of COVID-19-associated cough remains unclear, although guidelines for current approaches to acute and chronic cough serve as reference
  • •COVID-19 cough might result from the invasion of vagal sensory neurons by SARS-CoV-2 or a neuroinflammatory response, or both, leading to peripheral and central hypersensitivity of cough pathways
  • •Studies are needed to provide data on the epidemiology and effect on quality of life of post-COVID chronic cough, together with insights into the cough hypersensitive state
  • •The hypothesis that the post-COVID syndrome results from a neuroinflammatory response affecting various regions of the brain to induce chronic fatigue, pain, dyspnoea, and cough should be addressed
  • •Although neuromodulators such as gabapentin or opioids might be considered for COVID-19 cough, new anti-inflammatories or neuromodulators could be considered to treat not only cough, but also the post-COVID syndrome; randomised studies are needed to examine the efficacy and safety of potential treatments during the acute and chronic phases of disease

Acute COVID-19-associated cough

Dry cough is one of the most common initial symptoms of COVID-19, reported in about 60–70% of symptomatic patients.1, 2, 5 Using an app-based COVID symptom tracker on smartphones, cough was reported in about 50% of patients who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, and in combination with a loss of smell (anosmia), loss of taste (ageusia), unusual fatigue, and loss of appetite, was highly predictive of SARS-CoV-2 infection.6 

A systematic review and meta-analysis7 of 21 682 adults infected with SARS-CoV-2 in nine countries reported that cough was present in 57%. A study in Wuhan, China, found that the median time from illness onset to cough was 1 day and that cough persisted for an average of 19 days; cough lasted for 4 weeks or more in approximately 5% of patients.2

The co-presence of cough, anosmia, and ageusia 6 indicates that neuroinflammatory mechanisms might be operative in COVID-19 pathogenesis. As the cough reflex is mediated by the vagus nerve,8 interactions between the virus and the airway vagus nerve, with ensuing neuroinflammation, represent the likely primary events for the initiation of cough.

Cough in the post-COVID syndrome

An increasing number of reports describes an array of fluctuating or persistent symptoms experienced by patients for months after recovery from COVID-19. Symptoms include cough, fatigue, dyspnoea, pain, and so-called brain fog (cognitive impairment, including confusion and memory loss), and are associated with a deleterious effect on activities of daily living.9, 10, 11 

This phenomenon has been termed the post-COVID syndrome or long COVID.12, 13 A study by Carfi and colleagues14 was the first to describe persistent symptoms in patients after COVID-19. In a post-COVID cohort of 143 patients from a hospital in Italy, 125 (87·4%) reported struggling with symptoms—76 (53·1%) reported fatigue, 62 (43·4%) dyspnoea, and 23 (16·0%) cough—2 months after discharge.14 

Many reports have now described post-COVID symptoms and show that cough can persist for weeks and months after SARS-CoV-2 infection in some patients, with differing severity of acute symptoms (figure 1 , table 1 ).9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29

An external file that holds a picture, illustration, etc.
Object name is gr1_lrg.jpg

Figure 1

Follow-up studies reporting persistent cough in patients with post-COVID syndrome

Studies sorted by follow-up duration in ascending order from left to right. Follow-up duration ranges from 6 weeks to 6 months. Data were retrieved from available publications, including peer-reviewed papers and preprints.9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26 Detailed characteristics of each study are summarised in table 1. Some studies did not report acute cough data.

Table 1

Studies reporting cough at follow-up in patients with COVID-19

Study design and regionPatientsFollow-up durationAcute cough (%)Persistent cough (%)Other common persistent symptoms
Clinic-based studies
Cheng et al, 2021 15Retrospective, multicentre cohort study; London, UK113 patients discharged from the respiratory unit after COVID-19; median age 65 years6 weeks after dischargeNot reported19 of 113 (17%)Fatigue (67%), breathlessness (38%)
Moradian et al, 2020 16Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Tehran, Iran200 patients (160 [80%] men, 40 [20%] women) discharged from hospital after moderate-to-severe COVID-19; mean age 55·6 years6 weeks after discharge88 of 200 (44·0%)23 of 200 (11·5%)Fatigue (19·5%), dyspnoea (18·5%), weakness (18·0%), anxiety (15·0%), activity intolerance (14·5%)
Halpin et al, 2021 10Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Leeds, UK100 patients (56 [56%] men, 44 [44%] women) discharged from hospital after COVID-19; mean age 66·6 yearsMean 48 (SD 10·3) days after dischargeNot reported21 of 100 (21%) overall; eight of 32 (25%) ICU patients and eight of 68 (12%) ward patientsFatigue (64%), breathlessness (50%)
Mandal et al, 2020 13Prospective, multicentre follow-up study; London, UK384 patients (238 [62%] men, 146 [38%] women) hospitalised with COVID-19; mean age 59·9 yearsMedian 54 (IQR 47–59) days after dischargeNot reported131 of 384 (34%) persistent cough (numerical rating scale ≥1); 38 of 384 (10%), burdensome cough (numerical rating scale ≥4)Fatigue (69·0%), breathlessness (53·1%), depression (14·6%)
D’Cruz et al, 2021 17Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; London, UK119 patients (74 [62%] men, 45 [38%] women) hospitalised with severe COVID-19 pneumonia; mean age 58·7 yearsMedian 61 (IQR 51–67) days after dischargeNot reported49 of 115 (42·6%) persistent cough (numerical rating scale ≥1); eight of 115 (7·0%) burdensome cough (numerical rating scale ≥4)Fatigue (67·8%), sleep disturbance (56·5%), pain (49·6%)
Chopra et al, 2020 18Prospective, multicentre follow-up survey; MI, USA488 survivors of COVID-19 hospitalisation (253 [51·8%] men, 235 [48·2%] women); mean age 62 years60 days after dischargeNot reported75 of 488 (15·4%) new or worsened coughEmotional impact (48·8%), breathlessness walking up stairs (23·0%), shortness of breath or chest tightness or wheezing (16·6%), loss of taste or smell (13·1%)
Carfi et al, 2020 14Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Rome, Italy143 patients (90 [63%] men, 53 [37%] women) discharged from hospital after COVID-19; mean age 56·5 yearsMean 60·3 (SD 13·6) days after symptom onset99 of 143 (69%)23 of 143 (16%)Fatigue (53·1%), dyspnoea (43·4%), joint pain (27·3%), chest pain (21·7%)
Arnold et al, 2021 19Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Bristol, UK110 patients (62 [56%] men, 28 [44%] women) hospitalised with laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection; median age 60 yearsMedian 90 (IQR 80–97) days after symptom onset74 of 110 (67%)13 of 110 (11·8%)Excessive fatigue (39%), breathlessness (39%), insomnia (24%)
Sonnweber et al, 2020 20Prospective, multicentre follow-up study; Austria145 patients (83 [57%] men, 62 [43%] women) who required hospitalisation (75%) or outpatient care with persisting symptoms; mean age 57 yearsMean 100 (SD 21) days after symptom onset102 of 145 (70%)25 of 145 (17%)Dyspnoea (36%), sleep disorder (28%), night sweat (24%), pain (24%), hyposmia or anosmia (19%)
Xiong et al, 2021 21Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Wuhan, China538 patients (245 [45·5%] men, 293 [54·5%] women) discharged from hospital after COVID-19; median age 52 yearsAt least 3 months after discharge297 of 538 (55·2%)38 of 538 (7·1%)Alopecia (28·6%), fatigue (28·3%), sweating (23·6%), somniopathy (17·7%), chest distress (14·1%)
Zhao et al, 2020 22Retrospective, multicentre follow-up study; Zhengzhou, China55 patients (32 [58·2%] men, 23 [41·8%] women) discharged from hospital (51 patients had pneumonia); median age 47·7 years3 months after discharge30 of 55 (54·5%)1 of 55 (1·8%)Gastrointestinal symptoms (30·9%), headache (18·2%), fatigue (16·4%), exertional dyspnoea (14·6%)
Valiente-De Santis et al, 2020 (pre-print) 23Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Malaga, Spain108 patients (48 [44·4%] men, 60 [55·6%] women) discharged from admission or emergency service care; mean age 55·5 years12 weeks after acute phaseNot reported28 of 108 (25·9%)Dyspnoea (55·6%), asthenia (44·9%), chest pain (25·9%), palpitation (22·2%)
Wong et al, 2020 11Prospective, multicentre follow-up study; Vancouver, Canada78 patients (50 [64%] men, 28 [36%] women) hospitalised with laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection; mean age 62 yearsMedian 13 (IQR 11–14) weeks after symptom onsetNot reported18 of 78 (23%)Dyspnoea (50%)
Garrigues et al, 2020 9Prospective, single-centre follow-up study; Paris, France120 patients (75 [62·5%] men, 45 [37·5%] women) discharged from hospital after COVID-19; mean age 63·2 yearsMean 110·9 days after admission87 of 120 (72·5%) overall; 69 of 96 (71·9%) ward patients and 18 of 24 (75·0%) ICU patients20 of 120 (16·7%) overall; 14 of 96 (14·6%) ward patients and six of 24 (25·0%) ICU patientsFatigue (55·0%), dyspnoea (42·0%), loss of memory (34·0%), sleep disorder (30·8%), concentration disorder (28·0%)
Stavem et al, 2020 24Prospective geographical cohort study; Norway (areas covering 17% of the population)451 non-hospitalised patients (198 [44%] men, 253 [56%] women) with positive PCR; mean age 49·8 yearsMedian 117 (range 41–193) days after symptom onset302 of 451 (67%) dry cough; 12 of 451 (28%) productive cough27 of 451 (6%) dry cough; 18 of 451 (4%) productive coughDyspnoea (16%), loss of smell (12%), loss of taste (10%), arthralgia (9%), myalgia (8%)
Petersen et al, 2020 25Prospective geographical cohort study; Faroe Islands180 non-hospitalised patients (83 [46%] men, 97 [54%] women) with positive PCR; mean age 39·9 yearsMean 125 days after symptom onset73 of 180 (40·5%) dry cough; 46 of 180 (25·5%) productive coughNine of 180 (5%) dry cough; 11 of 180 (6%) productive coughFatigue (29%), loss of smell (24%), loss of taste (15%), arthralgia (10%), rhinorrhoea (9%)
Guler et al, 2021 27Prospective, multicentre follow-up study; Switzerland113 patients (67 [59·3%] men, 46 [40·7%] women) who survived acute COVID-19 (66 patients had severe or critical disease; 47 had mild or moderate disease); mean age 57 yearsMedian 128 (IQR 108–144) days after symptom onsetNot reportedNot reported; cough VAS median 0 (IQR 0–2)..
Klein et al, 2021 26Prospective follow-up study of PCR-positive patients with COVID-19 recruited via social media and word of mouth; Israel112 patients (72 [64·3%] men, 40 [35·7%] women; six hospitalised and 106 ambulatory patients) in recovery after COVID-19; mean age 35 years6 weeks and 6 months after symptom onset68 of 112 (61%)29 of 112 (26%) at 6 weeks; one of 112 (1%) at 6 monthsAt 6 months: fatigue (23%), smell change (15%), breathing difficulty (10%), taste change (8%), memory disorder (6%)
Online population-based surveys
Assaf et al, 2020 28Patient-led survey through the Body Politic COVID-19 Support Group on Slack (75·4% of participants) or through social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; 71·7% from the USA and UK, 12·7% from the USA and UK640 patients (150 [23·4%] men, 490 [76·6%] women) who had previously experienced or were currently experiencing symptoms consistent with COVID-19 and had suspected or confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection (23·1% tested positive, 27·5% tested negative, 47·8% not tested); 62·7% between the ages of 30 and 49 yearsUp to 8 weeks after symptom onsetAt week 1: 301 of 640 (47·0%) dry cough; 141 of 640 (22·0%) persistent uncontrollable coughAt week 8: 179 of 640 (28·0%) dry cough; 57 of 640 (8·9%) persistent uncontrollable coughMild shortness of breath (39%), mild chest tightness (34%), mild fatigue (33%), moderate fatigue (32%)
Sudre et al, 2020 (preprint)29Prospective cohort study of users of the COVID Symptom Study app4182 patients (1192 [28·5%] men, 2990 [71·5%] women) who had tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 by PCR swab testing and logged as “feeling physically normal” before the start of illness (up to 14 days before testing); mean age 42·8 years56 days after symptom onsetNot reported920 of 4182 (22%) persistent cough, defined as symptoms lasting more than 56 days..
Goërtz et al, 2020 12Online survey of individuals with persistent complaints related to COVID-19; the Netherlands and Belgium2133 members of Facebook groups for COVID-19 patients with persistent complaints and a panel of people who registered at a website of the Lung Foundation Netherlands (309 [14·5%] men, 1824 [85·3%] women); mean age 47 yearsMean 79 (SD 17) days after symptom onset1450 of 2133 (68·0%)619 of 2133 (29·0%)Fatigue (94·9%), dyspnoea (89·5%), headache (76·0%), chest tightness (75·2%), muscle pain (64·7%)

Studies are listed by follow-up duration from 6 weeks to 6 months. ICU=intensive care unit. VAS=visual analogue scale.

What is the prevalence of post-COVID cough?

In a multicentre observational cohort study done in 1250 COVID-19 survivors in Michigan, USA, 75 (15·4%) of those who responded to the telephone survey reported new or worsening cough at 2 months after discharge.18 Persistent cough was also reported in patients with mild baseline severity;24, 25 cohort studies in Norway and the Faroe Islands found that about 10% of their non-hospitalised patients had cough at 4 months after symptom onset.24, 25 

In a pooled analysis, we found that the estimated prevalence of persistent cough was 18% (95% CI 12–24%; I 2=93%) in 14 studies of hospitalised patients (follow-up duration ranged from 6 weeks to 4 months; figure 2 ) .9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 However, prevalence varied widely between studies, and is presumably dependent on patient characteristics, treatment, follow-up duration, and outcome definition.

An external file that holds a picture, illustration, etc.
Object name is gr2_lrg.jpg

Figure 2

Prevalence of post-COVID cough in 14 studies of patients who required hospitalisation

Follow-up duration ranges from 6 weeks to 4 months. Detailed characteristics of included studies are summarised in table 1.9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 We conducted a random-effects meta-analysis to estimate the pooled prevalence and standard errors for post-COVID-cough in previously hospitalised patients, and quantified the degree of heterogeneity between studies using the I2 in the MetaXL 5.3 software (EpiGear International Pty, Sunrise Beach, QLD, Australia).

Longitudinal studies in the general population have not been reported so far, but in the UK Office for National Statistics COVID-19 Infection Survey, the proportion of patients who remain symptomatic at 5 weeks after infection was estimated at 21·0% (95% CI 19·9–22·1%), and cough was the second most common persistent symptom (11·4% [10·5–12·2%]), fatigue being the first.30 The estimated prevalence of patients symptomatic at 12 weeks was 9·9% (6·7–14·7%), but a specific rate for cough has not yet been reported.30 In online surveys, cough was reported in 20–30% of still symptomatic patients 2–3 months after the onset of symptoms of COVID-19 (table 1).12, 28, 29

Two studies provided information on the prevalence of burdensome cough after COVID-19 (arbitrarily defined as cough with a numerical rating scale ≥4) and indicated that 7–10% of patients who recovered from COVID-19 pneumonia might suffer from burdensome cough 2 months after discharge.13, 17 However, more data are needed on the prevalence, severity, effects, and long-term course of post-COVID cough.

What are the causes of post-COVID cough?

It is not known why the post-COVID syndrome develops in some individuals. There is emerging evidence that female sex, presence of respiratory comorbidites, and severity of acute COVID-19 presentation might be predictive of post-COVID syndrome.9, 10, 20, 24, 31 

So far, it is unclear whether any factors in the acute phase could specifically determine the persistence of cough. Unlike cough that persists after the common cold or flu, chronic cough in post-COVID syndrome is usually accompanied by other multisystem manifestations, which might indicate either multifactorial pathogenesis or shared mechanisms underlying these symptoms.

The concomitant presence of fatigue, dyspnoea, pain, and cough could point to a derangement of the CNS. Therefore, documentation of the extent and quality of these co-existing symptoms is an important goal. From the point of view of cough, detailed characterisation—including frequency, severity, urge to cough, hypersensitivity, or cough suppressibility—using clinical tools that are already available could improve our understanding of its clinical implications and relationship to the other post-COVID symptoms.

In the clinical management of post-COVID chronic cough, it is important to exclude any pathological or structural causes, such as fibrotic damage to the lung parenchyma32 or damage to the airways caused by either SARS-CoV-2 or the treatment provided in critical care.

Lung parenchymal changes are commonly found on CT scans of adult patients with COVID-19, and lung fibrotic changes can occur in 10–20% of patients.32 Lung fibrosis could increase cough reflex sensitivity in response to mechanical stimulation of the chest wall, as reported in patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.33

Neuronal mechanisms of cough

There have been great advances in our understanding of the pathways underlying cough and cough hypersensitivity. Cough is a reflex that requires minimum conscious control, occurring through the activation of peripheral sensory nerves into the vagus nerves, which provide input to the brainstem at the solitary nucleus and the spinal trigeminal nucleus.8 

In chronic cough, the concept of cough hypersensitivity has been developed with the notion that the cough pathways have been sensitised by amplification of the afferent signals to the brainstem.34 In this Personal View, we postulate that neuronal mechanisms of hypersensitivity are central to the cough of COVID-19.

We consider the possibility that SARS-CoV-2 infects the sensory nerves mediating cough, leading to neuroinflammation and neuroimmune interactions as mechanisms of cough hypersensitivity (figure 3 ). We also examine whether the neurotropism of SARS-CoV-2 could explain the other accompanying symptoms of COVID-19 and post-COVID syndrome.

An external file that holds a picture, illustration, etc.
Object name is gr3_lrg.jpg
Figure 3
Proposed mechanisms of cough in SARS-CoV-2 infection
SARS-CoV-2 might induce cough via neuroinflammatory and neuroimmune mechanisms. (Left) Direct infection or viral recognition by vagal sensory neurons or sensory neuron-associated glial cells could promote a neuroinflammatory state, characterised by neuronal or glial release of neuroactive inflammatory mediators. Neuroinflammation could occur at the level of the nerve terminal in the airways and lungs, within the vagus nerve containing the neuronal axons, at the level of the vagal sensory ganglia containing neuronal cell bodies, or at sites within the CNS responsible for integrating vagal sensory inputs. Neuroinflammatory mediators include neuronally released interferons and glial-derived ATP, which are important for antiviral responses within the nervous system. (Right) Traditional inflammatory cells, including dendritic cells, macrophages, neutrophils, and epithelial cells, involved in SARS-CoV-2 infection and viral recognition can also release a broad range of inflammatory mediators, including antiviral interferons, cytokines, prostanoids, lipid mediators, and ATP. Many of these mediators can activate or sensitise vagal sensory nerves via cognate receptors or gating ion channels, providing a neuroimmune axis for alterations in vagal sensory neuron activity. Sensory neuron activation could enhance inflammation via the release of neuropeptides, which facilitate inflammatory cell recruitment and activation in a process known as neurogenic inflammation. Collectively, these cascades could upregulate sensory neuron activation and input to brain circuits mediating cough. ACE2=angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (or other viral entry factors). IFNAR=interferon receptor. P2X2/3=purinergic receptors. TLRs=toll-like receptors. TNFR=tumour necrosis factor receptor. TRPs=transient receptor potential channels.

Does SARS-CoV-2 infect sensory nerves?

Angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) receptors and proteases such as transmembrane serine protease 2 (TMPRSS2) and furin are important for viral entry into host cells for coronaviruses such as SARS-CoV-2.35 SARS-CoV-2 might interact directly with sensory neurons, given that sensory dysfunction—including cough, and olfactory and taste impairments—are frequent in infected patients.6

However, it is not known whether human airway vagal sensory neurons express ACE2 or TMPRSS2, or can be infected by SARS-CoV-2. In mice, single-cell sequencing of bronchopulmonary vagal sensory neurons showed no expression of murine ACE2.36 Additional viral entry factors might also have a role in the interactions of SARS-CoV-2 with neurons, including neuropilin-1, which is expressed by vagal and other sensory neurons.37

In a sequencing study of human olfactory mucosal cells, ACE2 and TMPRSS2 were not found in olfactory epithelial neurons, but were abundantly expressed in olfactory epithelial support cells and stem cells.38 The findings were confirmed by cellular histological localisation of ACE2 in the specialised neuroepithelium of supporting cells around neuronal dendritic projections; the neuroepithelium contains odour-sensing cilia.39

Therefore, anosmia induced by SARS-CoV-2 infection might be caused by the effect of the infected epithelium on neuronal activity. However, the ACE2 gene has been reported in a subset of human dorsal root ganglion sensory neurons in the thoracic ganglia, some of which also innervate the lungs. Notably, expression was reported in a subset of nociceptive neurons co-expressing CALCA (calcitonin related polypeptide alpha) or P2RX3 (purinergic receptor P2X3),40 and comparable neuronal subtypes of the vagal sensory ganglia are important for the induction of coughing.

The fact that some vagal sensory neurons, including those involved in cough, have a developmental lineage and molecular phenotype that is very similar to dorsal root ganglion neurons41 means that ACE2 expression in human vagal sensory neurons might be predicted.

Although the infection of dorsal root ganglion neurons containing nociceptors might provide an explanation for the post-COVID symptoms of joint and chest pain, headache, and dyspnoea, the basis for sustained cough after SARS-CoV-2 infection remains unclear. A post-mortem study42 of individuals who died with COVID-19 has reported the presence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA and protein in the olfactory mucosa, confirming entry of the virus into the CNS at a neural–mucosal surface.

In the same study,42 the trigeminal sensory ganglia, which innervate the corneal, nasal, and oral epithelium, also contained virus, suggesting that sensory neurons can offer an entry point for SARS-CoV-2 to the CNS. SARS-CoV-2 has also been shown to infect brain organoids in vitro, and the brains of human ACE-expressing transgenic mice after in-vivo intranasal inoculation.43

There is evidence in animals that some respiratory viruses can reach the brainstem and the brain by the retrograde route, through infection of the sensory vagal fibres from the respiratory tract.44 Alternatively, mechanisms might exist that trigger responses in the brain independent of intact viral particles, as shed S1 spike protein of SARS-CoV-2 can cross the blood–brain barrier in mice via absorptive transcytosis.45 Further work is needed to investigate these possible direct viral–neural interactions in the pathogenesis of cough and other sensory symptoms during SARS-CoV-2 infection.

Does SARS-CoV-2 alter sensory neuronal function?

Viral infection of neurons, including herpes virus infection of primary sensory neurons, leads to the activation of neuronal antiviral signalling, which can include the production of interferons and other cytokines traditionally involved in cellular defence against viral infection.46

Additionally, neuronal support cells (such as glial cells) respond to neuronal infection by generating a local inflammatory environment.47 It is now clear that release of cytokines—the so-called cytokine storm—can occur in severe COVID-19 infection, characterised by increased levels of inflammatory cytokines including tumour necrosis factor (TNF) and interleukin (IL)-6, which are associated with increased mortality.1, 48

In the peripheral nervous system, traditional immune cells, including macrophages and dendritic cells, infiltrate nerves and neuronal tissues to assist with inflammatory reactions.49 Collectively, these neuroinflammatory processes would be expected to dramatically alter sensory neuron activity and potentially underpin cough induction and persistence.50

Alternatively, as sensory neurons commonly express Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and other receptors for recognition of pathogenic organisms, direct functional interactions between viral particles and nerves might occur in the absence of neuronal infection. Indeed, in dorsal root ganglion neurons, TLR activation leads to gating of transient receptor potential (TRP) channels, offering a mechanism by which pathogens can directly change neuronal activity independent of viral entry.51 Further studies are warranted to explore the interactions between SARS-CoV-2 and vagal sensory neurons with their supportive cells.

The very rapid onset of cough after SARS-CoV-2 infection2 might suggest a mechanism independent of a direct nerve–virus interaction. For example, an initial epithelium-derived mechanism could evolve to be sustained by dysregulated inflammation. In addition to TLRs, cytokines released through dysregulated inflammation caused by SARS-CoV-2 activation of the innate immune response (eg, through inflammasome activation) are likely candidates driving acute cough via neuroimmune interactions.

These cytokines include IL-1β, TNF, and interferons, because their receptors are commonly present on immune cells and peripheral neurons.52 Type I and type II interferons, such as interferon-γ, might cause cough hyper-responsiveness through depolarisation of vagal sensory neurons.53, 54

Neuropeptides released from sensory nerves through activation of TRPV1, such as substance P, neurokinin A, and calcitonin gene-related peptide, can recruit and activate immune cells (eg, lymphocyte and dendritic cells) and inflammatory cells (eg, mast cells and macrophages), and increase vascular permeability, thereby aggravating lung inflammation.52, 55

Various ligand–receptor interactions after SARS-CoV-2 infection at the level of the dorsal root ganglion have been proposed to induce a neurogenic inflammation.56 Support cells of peripheral sensory neurons (myelinating and non-myelinating glia) can additionally contribute to viral recognition and inflammation, and alter sensory neuron responsivity.57, 58 One product of inflammasome activation is ATP, which might activate or sensitise cough receptors directly.52, 59

Is COVID-19 cough the result of sensory hypersensitive pathways?
The mechanisms of cough in the context of other respiratory viruses might provide further insight into the mechanisms of acute COVID-19 cough. Human rhinovirus (HRV)-16, a major pathogen for the common cold and asthma exacerbations, can infect sensory neurons and upregulate TRP channels,60 which could explain the heightened cough reflex and urge-to-cough sensations in patients with common cold.61 In A549 alveolar epithelial cells, HRV-16 infection significantly increased not only intracellular ATP concentrations, but also the extracellular release of ATP,62 which is a highly relevant mediator for chronic refractory cough.63 In guinea pigs, infection with parainfluenza type 3 virus caused phenotypic changes of sensory neuronal hypersensitivity in the tracheal nodose neurons, including de-novo expression of substance P or TRPV1.64, 65 Therefore, sensory hypersensitivity is likely to underlie virus-associated cough in general, although specific mechanisms might vary between different respiratory viruses (figure 3).

Urge to cough, frequently seen in subjects with common cold and possibly also in those with acute COVID-19-associated cough, has been linked to altered central processing of sensory input and cough reflex (termed central sensitisation).66 Substance P, which might be upregulated in the nodose ganglionic neurons by viral infection,64 can drive central sensitisation in virus-associated cough.

Murine pneumovirus infection induced inflammatory glial cell activation and altered neuronal responsiveness in the brainstem nucleus tractus solitarius of mice, the primary site of vagal sensory inputs.67 Therefore, increased inflammatory activation of sensory neurons could induce altered reflex processing in the brain.

In ACE2 transgenic mice infected with SARS-CoV, brain areas that have first-order or second-order connections with the olfactory bulb were heavily infected, including the dorsal vagal complex, area postrema, and dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus, which are also implicated in cough regulation.68 SARS-CoV-2 can be found in the brain and cerebrospinal fluid of patients with COVID-19,69 suggesting that this virus is likely to be detectable by microglia and macrophage-like immune cells, which might orchestrate inflammation in the brain and provide a central basis for hypersensitivity.

This response could, in turn, influence peripheral mechanisms of hypersensitivity. A post-mortem analysis of individuals who died of COVID-19 found the pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-6, IL-18, and C-C motif chemokine 2 (CCL2) in the cerebrospinal fluid, and SARS-CoV-2 virus in the brainstem medulla.42 Notably, SARS-CoV-2 was detected in brainstem regions involved in respiratory control, perhaps a neuroanatomical basis for effects on breathing and associated reflexes in COVID-19.

Is the post-COVID syndrome due to a generalised neuronal hypersensitivity?

An important consideration is whether the post-COVID syndrome is the result of a generalised hypersensitivity state that underlies the panoply of symptoms associated with this condition. Key symptoms reported in post-COVID syndrome (dyspnoea, pain, and cough) have similarities in terms of the control and peripheral sensitisation of their respective afferent pathways.70

We have shown that idiopathic chronic cough, now often described as the cough hypersensitivity syndrome, is dominated by the presence of a hypersensitivity with both peripheral and central components.34 The central neurobiology of cough hypersensitivity has been supported by functional brain imaging of airway stimulation with a tussive TRPV1 agonist, capsaicin, which showed elevated neural activity in the midbrain of individuals with this syndrome.71

Chronic fatigue syndrome (also called myalgic encephalomyelitis) and fibromyalgia, in which patients complain of fatigue and musculoskeletal pain, have also been associated with alterations in pain and sensory processing in both peripheral and central neurogenic sensitisation.72, 73 Functional MRI studies have shown that the insular and cingulate cortices are key areas in the nociceptive processing of dyspnoea, which are the same areas activated by pain and cough.70, 71, 74

Therefore, we need to gather evidence to explore shared or common features in the pathways of central hypersensitivity, encompassing not only post-COVID hypersensitive cough, but also the whole post-COVID syndrome. Indeed, brain MRI imaging of patients with neurological complications of COVID-19 infection have shown cortical signal abnormalities and neuroinflammatory features,75 and brain PET imaging suggests hypometabolism in the olfactory gyrus and connected limbic and paralimbic regions, extending to the brainstem and the cerebellum in patients with long COVID.76

Management of COVID-19-associated cough

The advice for treating the acute and chronic cough of COVID-19 is based on available treatments and guidelines.77, 78 Although many drugs are on the market or in development for the relief of cough,79 there is no good evidence for their benefits in the treatment of cough associated with acute viral infection or pneumonia.80, 81

In the UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidelines for managing acute symptoms of COVID-19, only taking honey or opioid-derived antitussives are recommended for cough.82 Opiates (such as codeine or low-dose morphine) could exert antitussive effects by acting on the cough reflex network in the brainstem,83 and might have some effects in suppressing cough, particularly in the early stages. However, opiates are not universally effective and have associated risks of dependence, abuse, or central side-effects.83

Oral corticosteroids are often prescribed for acute lower respiratory tract infection and have been used by many centres to treat patients with post-COVID interstitial lung changes. Oral corticosteroids were no better than placebo in reducing cough duration in non-asthmatic adults with acute lower respiratory tract infection.84

However, the situation with SARS-CoV-2 infection might be different, with the likely presence of an early inflammatory response and neuroimmune interactions underlying the acute cough. The report that dexamethasone reduces the mortality rate of hospital-treated patients with COVID-19 provides some support for the use of corticosteroids.85, 86 However, cough was not assessed in these trials,85, 86 nor was it measured in any other trials of therapies for COVID-19, such as the study of the antiviral replicating agent remdesivir.87 Cough measurements should be incorporated into future trials.

Anatomical diagnostic protocols for chronic cough77 should be applied for the management of cough in the post-COVID syndrome; such approaches could identify any contributing causes to chronic cough—such as gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, ACE inhibitor therapy, lung fibrosis, or airway inflammation—that might have resulted from COVID-19 infection.

Persistent cough in post-COVID syndrome might be driven by neuroinflammation leading to a state of laryngeal and cough hypersensitivity, which is the basis for chronic refractory or unexplained cough. Gabapentin and pregabalin, which are neuromodulators, have been shown to be effective in controlling chronic refractory cough.88, 89

This approach could be considered for the post-COVID syndrome, because these drugs might also be useful for other symptoms accompanying cough, such as pain, although they have the potential to worsen any cognitive dysfunction.

Antimuscarinic drugs, such as tiotropium, could be used to control COVID-19 cough, because they can decrease cough sensitivity in acute viral upper respiratory tract infection.90

Similarly, speech and language therapy91 might help patients to recover, delivered as part of a multimodal therapy and recovery model in synergy with other aspects of pulmonary rehabilitation for the post-COVID syndrome.

Investigation of novel therapeutic interventions that interfere with the neuroinflammatory pathways could be advantageous, such as inhibitors of TRP channels, ATP-gated P2X3 receptors, neurokinin-1 receptors (NK1Rs), or sodium channels. A P2X3 receptor antagonist, gefapixant, substantially reduced cough in patients with chronic refractory cough,63 and its use in COVID-19-associated cough is supported by the report that ACE2 is frequently co-expressed with P2X3 in dorsal root ganglion sensory neurons.40

Substance P and NK1R might also be a potential target for intervention, because NK1R antagonists such as aprepitant or orvepitant have shown antitussive potential in patients with lung cancer-associated cough or chronic refractory cough, possibly through blocking of central NK1Rs.92, 93

Although TRPV1 antagonists have not been shown to reduce cough in patients with refractory cough,94, 95 they should be tested in COVID-19 cough because TRPV1 in sensory neurons is upregulated by viral infections such as human rhinovirus.60 The charged sodium channel blocker NTX-1175, which silences nociceptor neurons, is a new neuromodulator that is being trialled (EuraCT 2020-004715-27) for chronic cough, but could also be considered for acute and chronic COVID-19 cough.

reference link : https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8041436/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Questo sito usa Akismet per ridurre lo spam. Scopri come i tuoi dati vengono elaborati.