Working out just five minutes daily via a practice described as “strength training for your breathing muscles” lowers blood pressure and improves some measures of vascular health as well as, or even more than, aerobic exercise or medication, new CU Boulder research shows.
The study, published today in the Journal of the American Heart Association, provides the strongest evidence yet that the ultra-time-efficient maneuver known as High-Resistance Inspiratory Muscle Strength Training (IMST) could play a key role in helping aging adults fend off cardiovascular disease––the nation’s leading killer.
In the United States alone, 65% of adults over age 50 have above-normal blood pressure – putting them at greater risk of heart attack or stroke. Yet fewer than 40% meet recommended aerobic exercise guidelines.
“There are a lot of lifestyle strategies we know can help people maintain cardiovascular health as they age. But the reality is, they take a lot of time and effort and can be expensive and hard for some people to access,” said lead author Daniel Craighead, an assistant research professor in the Department of Integrative Physiology. “IMST can be done in five minutes in your own home while you watch TV.”
Developed in the 1980s as a way to help critically ill respiratory disease patients strengthen their diaphragm and other inspiratory (breathing) muscles, IMST involves inhaling vigorously through a hand-held device which provides resistance. Imagine sucking hard through a tube that sucks back.
Initially, when prescribing it for breathing disorders, doctors recommended a 30-minute-per-day regimen at low resistance. But in recent years, Craighead and colleagues at the University of Arizona have been testing whether a more time-efficient protocol – 30 inhalations per day at high resistance, six days per week – could also reap cardiovascular, cognitive and sports performance improvements.
How the study worked
For the new study, they recruited 36 otherwise healthy adults ages 50 to 79 with above normal systolic blood pressure (120 millimeters of mercury or higher). Half did High-Resistance IMST for six weeks; and half did a placebo protocol, in which the resistance was much lower. Participants didn’t know which group they were in.
When assessed after six weeks, the IMST group saw their systolic blood pressure (the top number) dip nine points on average, a reduction which generally exceeds that achieved by walking 30 minutes a day five days a week. That decline is also equal to the effects of some blood pressure-lowering drug regimens.
Even six weeks after they quit doing IMST, they maintained most of that improvement.
“We found not only is it more time-efficient than traditional exercise programs, the benefits may be longer lasting,” Craighead said.
The treatment group also saw a 45% improvement in vascular endothelial function, or the ability for arteries to expand upon stimulation, and a significant increase in levels of nitric oxide, a molecule key for dilating arteries and preventing plaque buildup. Nitric oxide levels naturally decline with age.
Markers of inflammation and oxidative stress, which can also boost heart attack risk, were significantly lower after people did IMST for six weeks.
And, remarkably, those in the IMST group completed 95% of the sessions.
“We have identified a novel form of therapy that lowers blood pressure without giving people pharmacological compounds and with much higher adherence than aerobic exercise,” said senior author Doug Seals, a Distinguished Professor of Integrative Physiology. “That’s noteworthy.”
Promise for postmenopausal women
The practice may be particularly helpful for postmenopausal women.
In previous research, Seals’ lab showed that postmenopausal women who are not taking supplemental estrogen don’t reap as much benefit from aerobic exercise programs as men do when it comes to vascular endothelial function. IMST, the new study showed, improved it just as much in these women as in men.
“If aerobic exercise won’t improve this key measure of cardiovascular health for postmenopausal women, they need another lifestyle intervention that will,” said Craighead. “This could be it.”
Preliminary results from the same group suggest IMST also improved some measures of brain function and physical fitness. And previous studies from other researchers have shown it can be useful for improving sports performance.
“If you’re running a marathon, your respiratory muscles get tired and begin to steal blood from your skeletal muscles,” said Craighead, who uses IMST in his own marathon training. “The idea is that if you build up endurance of those respiratory muscles, that won’t happen and your legs won’t get as fatigued.”
Seals said they’re uncertain exactly how a maneuver to strengthen breathing muscles ends up lowering blood pressure, but they suspect it prompts the cells lining blood vessels to produce more nitric oxide, enabling them to relax.
The National Institutes of Health recently awarded Seals $4 million to launch a larger follow-up study of about 100 people, comparing a 12-week IMST protocol head-to-head with an aerobic exercise program.
Meanwhile, the research group is developing a smartphone app to enable people to do the protocol at home using already commercially available devices.
They say the practice is not necessarily meant to replace exercise but can be a useful option for those who lack access to walking trails or recreation centers, have trouble doing aerobic activities due to health reasons or just want to add another tool to their blood-pressure-lowering toolbox.
In an editorial accompanying the journal publication, researchers not involved in the study called for more research on the myriad health benefits, including potentially mental health benefits, the practice may hold.
Those considering IMST should consult with their doctor first. But thus far, IMST has proven remarkably safe, they said.
“It’s easy to do, it doesn’t take long, and we think it has a lot of potential to help a lot of people,” said Craighead.
Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is characterized by repeated airflow obstruction (apnea) and airflow limitation (hypopnea) that result in sleep disruption and chronic intermittent hypoxemia (CIH). CIH has been linked to increases in reactive oxygen species and oxidative stress that contribute to sympathetic nervous system (SNS) hyperactivity (10, 35, 48, 65) and hypertension in an estimated 30–70% of OSA adults (1). The standard of care for OSA worldwide is continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP), which delivers a steady stream of pressurized air via a (nasal/oral) mask to stent the upper airway and stabilize breathing and blood oxygenation. Among adults with OSA and hypertension, nightly CPAP use improves spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) (36, 67) and overall sympathetic nervous system activity (27, 39). However, these favorable outcomes are offset by uniformly low adherence, i.e., <4.4 h/night (18, 33, 38, 43), which continues to limit CPAP-related improvements in cardiovascular health (43).
Aerobic exercise is a first-line treatment for all stages of hypertension (74) and has well-documented benefits for blood pressure. Indeed, 2017 guidelines issued by the American Heart Association and American Cardiology Association advocate 150 min/week of aerobic exercise among the first-line treatments for all stages of hypertension (74) to lower blood pressure. Although traditional forms of aerobic exercise may improve BRS and lower blood pressure in OSA, the salient features of OSA including obesity [body mass index (BMI) >30] (19, 61, 75), lethargy (62, 66), and/or exercise intolerance (2, 6, 9, 26), often preclude sustained exertion (16, 41).
In recent years, a novel form of exercise known as inspiratory muscle strength training (IMST) has yielded surprising results including improvements in blood pressure and autonomic balance in patients with hypertension (23, 39) or OSA (70) and reductions in systemic vascular resistance in healthy young adults (17, 69). These outcomes are of interest and importance because in each case they were attained within 6 wk and with a training requirement of just 5 min/day for 5 days/wk or 25 min/wk total training time (70).
Whereas there is evidence that IMST performed daily lowers casual (resting) blood pressure and plasma catecholamines in adults with OSA and elevated or stage 1 hypertension (70), it is unclear what effect it may have on 24-h blood pressure, a better predictor of blood pressure related end-organ damage (25, 44). Accordingly, in the current study we obtained measures of casual and continuous, noninvasive ambulatory blood pressure monitoring in a cohort of older (60–80 yr), predominantly obese (i.e., BMI >30) adults with moderate-severe OSA [apnea hypopnea index (AHI) ≥15] pre-post 6-wk IMST.
Because OSA is a recognized cause of secondary hypertension and sympathetic nervous system activity plays a fundamental role in raising blood pressure in this population (11), we also performed microneurography to quantitate sympathetic neural activity directed to vascular smooth muscle [i.e., muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA)]. Last, whereas in a previous IMST study CPAP users had been excluded, the current study permitted inclusion of participants identified as adherent to CPAP or mandibular advancement devices (>4 h nightly use).
reference link : https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/japplphysiol.00024.2020
More information: Daniel H. Craighead et al, Time‐Efficient Inspiratory Muscle Strength Training Lowers Blood Pressure and Improves Endothelial Function, NO Bioavailability, and Oxidative Stress in Midlife/Older Adults With Above‐Normal Blood Pressure, Journal of the American Heart Association (2021). DOI: 10.1161/JAHA.121.020980
Michael J. Joyner et al, Take a Deep, Resisted, Breath, Journal of the American Heart Association (2021). DOI: 10.1161/JAHA.121.022203